I’m currently struggling through Salena Godden’s Mrs Death misses death, which I am supposed to write a comparative essay on (comparing it to Ali Smith’s Hotel World) due in a week and I’m still only halfway through the book – which is good, by the way; the reason I am struggling to read it is not a reflection on its quality or even evidence of a mismatch between it and my tastes, quite the opposite, it is very much in line with my tastes – I had expected this book to be a dark comedic fictional biography of Death, and a existential exploration of mortality, with the concept of life and death as an element through which to contextualise humanity, but, although there is some of that through the character of Mrs Death and her musings, the majority of the book is focused on the narrator’s first person accounts, either in prose or poetry, of their suicidal ideation… Now, the last thing you need to be reading when you are yourself a bipolar writer with consistently recurring battles with suicidal ideation, currently fending off the tailend of seasonal depression, is a first person narrative about a bipolar writer with suicidal ideation fending off the tailend of seasonal depression… because you will start to question your own sanity. In fact, you’d be mad not to.
Zooming out from this book, and my current predicament, for a moment. This is a real problem. Because suicidal ideation, suicidal thoughts and suicide are a serious problem. Whether you are actively suicidal, or a person struggling with suicidal ideation, or a person close to someone struggling with suicidal thoughts or, worse, a person who has lost someone to suicide, it is something that is as lonely as it is difficult to deal with. You need to talk to someone about it, but it is impossible to talk about. You need to try and understand it, to make sense of it, to name it so you can confront and fight it. But here is the rub… consuming media depicting themes of suicidal ideation, even when it’s not glamorised or romanticised, is known to exacerbate issues of suicidal ideation amongst those who struggle with it. Data shows that after a TV show with high viewing numbers has depicted scenes of this nature or generally deals with the theme of suicide (e.g. the Netflix show 13 reasons why) there is a recorded spike in both suicide hotline phone calls and actual attempts. But avoiding the topic altogether is also not the answer, because that adds to the social sigma and then this portion of the population who are struggling with thoughts of suicide are left to suffer in silence. I don’t know what the answer is, but I suppose responsible storytelling is the main thing. For example, Bradley Cooper’s film A star is born completely romanticises the main character’s suicide, which is completely irresponsible in my opinion, whereas the novel The Hours and its screen adaptation manages to toe the line in how it depicts the suicidal ideation and actual suicides of its respective central characters, even the suicide of Virginia Woolf herself, which is a feat, considering she made poetry out of her own suicide, lining her skirt with stones and walking into the rushing river.
If I compare The Hours and Mrs Death misses death, it’s hard to put my finger on the difference – maybe it is as simple as one being written in close third person and the other in first? – but one allows me to reflect on the subject of suicide, and of life and death, and come out the other side with a stronger will to live, and the other one… doesn’t.
However, my tutor assures me that the narrator ‘pulls through’ in the end, so I expect that is the way the story is heading. It is just taking its sweet time to get there, wallowing in the symptoms of manic depression and anxiety on the way, interspersed with Mrs Death’s accounts of various gruesome and violent deaths, including that of a child who was sexually assaulted, tortured and murdered by Ian Brady and Myra Hindley, so based on real events, which, after ages of Epstein files flooding my social media channels (until I logged off all of social media) has not been the most comforting of reads.
And the problem with my brain is, it won’t turn off. So now I’m haunted by images of children being tortured, imaginary children or my own, on top of questioning my own sanity. So all in all, I have no idea how I’m going to get this essay done in time…
Leave a Reply